Is Sexual Reproduction Important?

Sex is a necessity when referring to the survival of organisms. As stated by Dr. Tatiana in Dr. Tatiana’s Sex Advice To All Creation by Olivia Judson, sex is the mixing of genes, creating an organism with a new genetic makeup. A new genetic makeup is essential for evolution to occur, and happens through mutation and sex. However some organisms evolve to reproduce asexually, or without sex. Although asexual reproduction has its benefits, it can lead to extinction rapidly, making sexual reproduction better and thereby more important.

In “Wholly Virgin,” many arguments were stated that supported the opinion that sex is important. The Philodina roseola was claimed to have been reproducing asexually for the past 85 million years without the need for meiosis. However, the ram pointed out that chaetonotoid gastrotrichs, who also claimed to be ancient asexuals, were caught making sperm, an activity complying with the sexual reproduction rather than asexual reproduction, making it more likely for more organisms claiming to be ancient asexuals to in fact reproduce sexually.

In addition, according to Muller’s ratchet, by geneticist Hermann Muller, “asexuals are evolutionarily short-lived because” (226). This theory shows that sexual reproduction is better because asexual reproduction will lead to an evolutionary halt which is detrimental to the organism.

Another benefit stemming from sexual reproduction, is the lack of exposure to diseases and a better way to fight the disease. As stated when referring to asexual reproduction, asexual organisms are more vulnerable to the disease because all the organisms are the same. “...the disease has more chances to evolve to infiltrate the target” (229). But for those that reproduce sexually, the disease wouldn’t be able to affect everyone because the organisms that sexually reproduce would evolve to fight the disease rather than the disease evolving to fight the organism.

However, although the benefits of reproducing sexually outweigh those of asexual reproduction, there are some organisms that have been successful when reproducing asexually. Escherichia coli, commonly referred to as E. Coli, reproduce asexually, as they use binary fission, where they divide into two genetically identical cells. They then obtain new genes through sex.

As shown by Judson, the benefits of sexual reproduction clearly outweigh the benefits of asexual reproduction although there are downsides for both clearly mentioned.

But reading about viruses piqued my interest the most. I want to understand the specific processes on how viruses reproduce. I want to understand the specific processes, and how best scientists could target the reproduction process regarding the virus reproduction so that for example, a new flu vaccine to target influenza viruses will not need to be made annually and that one vaccine could stop the reproduction process.

Unit 3 Reflection

In this unit, we focused on cells. We focused on what cells are, what cells do, and the specific processes that take place inside the cell. Some of the main topics we covered this unit were diffusion and osmosis, the function and location of the organelles in the cell, photosynthesis, and cellular respiration.

We started this unit off learning about the cell in a general way, as in we learned what a cell was, what the cell theory was, and what was in a cell. But as the unit progressed, we learned more about the specific processes in the cell such as photosynthesis and cellular respiration, two particularly difficult aspects of this unit for me. The picture below shows the process of light-dependent reactions in photosynthesis.

Smaller processes such as osmosis and diffusion were easier to understand. Understanding osmosis and diffusion was particularly helpful when learning about membranes as those concepts explained how particles come in and out and what the job of the membrane is.

However, since I was also able to clearly understand what a cell was and the functions and locations of the organelles, I was finally able to understand what photosynthesis and cellular respiration were and how they took place.

But learning about photosynthesis and cellular respiration, two difficult topics for me, helped me adjust my learning and studying habits by spending more time on each topic and watching extra videos, when trying to understand the topics, making me a better student.

The video below helped me understand the topic of cellular respiration better.

                  Although this unit is over, I still wonder and am interested in understanding the timeframe in which photosynthesis and cellular respiration happen.

Egg Diffusion Lab

In this lab we asked the question, “How and why does a cell’s internal environment change, as its external environment changes?” We tested a hypotonic solution and a hypertonic solution on an egg and looked at their effects on the egg’s mass and circumference. We doused one of the eggs in sugar water creating a hypertonic solution. The other egg was placed in deionized water creating a hypotonic solution. We then compared the circumference and the mass of both the eggs.

When one of the eggs was placed in sugar water, the hypertonic solution, the egg shrunk  in circumference by an average of 22.1% and shrunk in mass by an average of 45.9%. When the other egg was placed in deionized water, the hypotonic solution, the egg grew by 7.78% regarding circumference but unexpectedly shrunk in mass by an average of 0.44%.

When placed in a hypertonic solution, the egg shrunk in both circumference and mass, as there was more solute outside of the cell than inside. That caused the egg to diffuse out the water from its membrane through passive diffusion, making it a higher concentration inside the cell and a lower concentration outside of the cell, which balances the concentration. For the egg placed in a hypotonic environment.

When the egg was placed in a hypotonic solution, the egg grew in size. Since in a hypotonic solution there there is more solute inside the cell than outside, the water from outside of the cell diffused through the membrane to dilute the concentration inside and higher the concentration outside of the cell, inevitably making the egg grow in size. However, during this egg diffusion lab, bigger solutes might have diffused out of the egg, causing the egg to lessen in mass, and more water could’ve diffused into the egg to dilute the high concentration in the cell, causing the egg to grow in size.

As a cell’s external environment changes, its internal environment is bound to get affected as the cell changes size and mass based on the hypotonic or hypertonic or other factors. This experiment showed how based on the concentration outside of the egg, the egg could change size, shape, and mass. If the egg was in a hypertonic solution, the egg shrunk. If the egg was in a hypotonic solution, the egg grew.

This lab showed the scientific concept of hypertonicity and hypotonicity and its effect on cells based on its environment. This lab explained why the cell will grow when it is in a hypotonic solution, which is because the cell will diffuse in more water to balance out the high concentration inside the cell. It also explained why the cell will shrink when it is in a hypertonic solution, which is because the cell will diffuse out more water to balance out the high concentration outside of the cell.

In our daily lives, fresh vegetables are often sprinkled with water, and roads are sometimes salted to melt ice. But these actions relate back to the concept of water tonicity. Fresh vegetables are often sprinkled with water to create a balance between the solvent and the solute, delaying the vegetable from spoiling. When the roads are often salted to melt ice, the plants alongside get affected, as it becomes a hypertonic environment. The concentration outside of the cell becomes higher than the inside of the cell, making it shrink and shrivel up, which is detrimental to the plants.

In the future, to build onto this experiment, we could look at different concentrations of the solute, outside of the cell to measure which is best for the cell. In this experiment we saw that when the egg was placed in a hypertonic solution, the egg shrunk, and when the egg was placed in a hypotonic solution, the egg grew. In the next experiment, we could again, use an egg, but use different concentrations of the sugar water to test what their effects would be on the egg. Also, we could test different chemicals, such as salt or common food ingredients, with different concentrations, and measure its effect on the cell.

24 hour time lapse of our Egg Diffusion Lab. Egg on left in corn syrup, egg on right in DH2O pic.twitter.com/wdfujQyBXM

— Mr. Orre's Class (@OrreBiology) October 5, 2016

Egg Macromolecules Lab

In this lab we asked the question “Can macromolecules be identified in an egg cell?” We found that the egg membrane tested positive for lipids. After adding the solution Sudan III, the indicator for lipids, the egg membrane turned orange, showing that it contained the macromolecule of lipids. The amount of lipids that showed up was rated a 7 on a scale of 1 to 10 when looking at how dark of an orange the membrane turned. Based on what we learned from previous vodcasts about cells, specifically “Intro to Cells,” the cell membrane is made up of lipids, specifically phospholipids. This evidence, coming from both the experiment and my previous knowledge from the vodcasts, supports our claim that the egg membrane tested positive for lipids, because membranes, including the egg membrane we tested, are made up of lipids.

In this lab, when testing the egg white, we found that it tested positive for monosaccharides. After adding the Benedict’s solution, the indicator for monosaccharides, the egg white turned from blue to green, showing that it had monosaccharides. We rated it a 10 out of a scale of 1 to 10 when again, looking at how dark the color was. Based on what we learned in previous vodcasts, again specifically “Intro to Cells,” we learned that cell walls are rich in carbohydrates, meaning that monosaccharides and polysaccharides are found in the cell wall. This data and evidence supports our claim that the egg white tested positive for monosaccharides, because in an egg, the egg white acts as the cell wall, meaning that the egg white will test positive for monosaccharides.

In addition to testing the egg membrane and the egg white, we tested the egg yolk in this lab, and we found that it tested positive for proteins. After adding both Sodium Hydroxide (NaOH) and the Copper Sulfate (CuSO4), the indicator for proteins, the yolk in the test tube turned from a blue color to a purple color, indicating that proteins were very evident in the egg yolk. Based on what we learned in again previous vodcasts, specifically “Into to Cells,” we learned that proteins are found in many different organelles in the cell. In addition based on previous knowledge, that the egg uses the yolk to develop into a chicken using structural proteins. This data and evidence supports our claim that the egg yolk tested positive for proteins, because the egg yolk contains many structural proteins.

While our hypothesis was supported by our data, there could have been errors due to the amount of the indicator solutions was used and the time it was left out. We were instructed to put 3 to 5 drops of the indicator solution into the part of the egg we were testing. This leaves it up to the scientist to decide how many drops they will put. Since there were four different people doing the experiment, the number of drops could have been different leading to results that aren’t as accurate as they could have been. This could have affected the results because the colors could have been darker, leading to different and less accurate numbers, regarding our quantitative observations. In addition, the ratings weren’t as accurate as it could have been, as there wasn’t a clear understanding between the 4 of us doing different parts of the experiment what each number meant on the scale of 1 to 10 when looking at how dark of a color appeared due to the drops of indicator solution in either the membrane, the yolk, or the egg white. This could have affected the results because a 1 could have been the same as someone’s 4, making the data invalid. Due to these errors, in future experiments, I would recommend doing the experiment only after discussing what each number in the scale of 1 to 10 means, and I would also recommend having a consensus regarding how many drops of the indicator solution we would have.

This lab was done to demonstrate and show us what macromolecules and in what concentration are found in different parts of the cell. From this lab, I learned that most of the macromolecules are found in most of the parts of the cell, but there is a very high concentration of lipids in the egg membrane, a very high concentration of monosaccharides in the egg white, and a very high concentration of proteins in the egg yolk, which helps me understand the concept of the location and job of the organelles and parts of the cell. Based on my experience from this lab I could apply this to other situations because this lab is able to tell me what I get from eggs in terms of carbohydrates, lipids, and proteins. This lab is able to give me a rough estimate on how much of each macromolecule is found in the egg, which will help me customize my meal after eating an egg, so I can get the right amount of protein and carbohydrates.